logo
logo
  • Home
  • Beauty
  • Health & Wellness
  • Jewelry
  • Grooming
  • Footwear
  • Sleep
  • Topics
    • Acne Care
    • Hair Care
    • Men's Care
    • Nutrition & Diet
    • Skin Care
    • Women's Care
  • Buyers Report
  • Health and Wellness

The Best Natural Toothpaste for Optimal Oral Health

Buyer's Report GUIDE Team
Written By Buyer's Report GUIDE Team
Last updated: Mar 27, 2025, 03:28 AM
Affiliate Disclosure ↓
Natural toothpaste

Our mouths are the gateways to our bodies, and what we put in them can make a huge difference. We all know the importance of brushing our teeth twice a day, but what might have been forgotten is the type of toothpaste we’re using. Natural toothpaste is becoming increasingly popular as it offers a number of health benefits that other toothpaste may not have.

In this article, we’ll explore the world of natural toothpaste and highlight some of the finest brands that will make your teeth feel clean and healthy. We’ll discuss the top features of natural toothpaste and look at the different types available on the market. Whether you’re looking for something that’s more gentle on your gums or something that freshens your breath and removes stains, you’ll be sure to find your perfect natural toothpaste in 2025.

View all Contents
  • Natural Toothpaste Buying Guide
    • Ingredients
    • Flouride Content
    • Taste
    • Texture
    • Whitening Power
    • Cost
    • Reviews
    • Brand Reputation
  • People Also Asked
  • Elevating the Shopping Game
  • Contributors
  • Related Reads

Our Top Picks of Natural Toothpaste

  • Weleda Salt Toothpaste: Best Overall (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this natural toothpaste ↓
  • Tom's of Maine Natural Toothpaste: Best Non-Foaming Formula (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this natural toothpaste ↓
  • Dr. Sheffield’s Natural Toothpaste: Most Refreshing Taste (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this natural toothpaste ↓
  • Native Natural Toothpaste: Most Natural and Clean-Feeling (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this natural toothpaste ↓
  • Davids Natural Toothpaste: Non-Toxic Ingredients (Shop Now) →
    Read more about this natural toothpaste ↓

Comparing the Top Natural Toothpaste of 2025

Weleda Salt Toothpaste

Best Overall
image
Check On Amazon

Refresh your mouth with the power of nature’s finest ingredients using Weleda Salt Toothpaste. This fluoride-free formula is crafted with sea salt and gentle mineral cleansers, working in harmony with your saliva’s natural enzymes to help flush away impurities and keep your mouth clean. Infused with ratanhia root, myrrh, and chestnut bark extracts, it helps tone and strengthen gums while gently polishing teeth. The zesty, salty taste is perfectly balanced with the freshness of peppermint essential oil, leaving your mouth feeling invigorated and naturally clean. Certified natural by NATRUE, this toothpaste is free from surfactants, synthetic preservatives, artificial flavors, and colorants, making it the best overall choice on our list for oral care. 

Product Pros
  • Fluoride-free and made with natural mineral cleansers
  • Strengthens and tones gums with botanical extracts
  • Gently polishes teeth for a clean, smooth feel
Product Cons
  • Does not contain fluoride, which some may prefer for cavity protection

Tom’s of Maine Natural Toothpaste

Best Non-Foaming Formula
image
Check On Amazon

Tom’s of Maine Fluoride-Free Antiplaque and Whitening Natural Toothpaste is an all-natural way to get a brighter, whiter smile. This two-pack provides five and a half ounces of peppermint flavor in each tube. It helps fight tartar buildup and remove surface stains from teeth with its antiplaque formula. 

The toothpaste is free of artificial sweeteners, preservatives, colors, and flavors. It is also cruelty-free and never tested on animals, making it a great option for those who care for their own health as well as their environment. It also comes in a recyclable tube that is easy to squeeze out and replace the cap on when finished. 

This option offers an easy way to clean and whiten your teeth without using fluoride. The all-natural ingredients make it safe for everyday use and help maintain a healthier mouth overall. Its peppermint flavor keeps mouths feeling refreshed after brushing. 

Product Pros
  • Freshens breath without being overly sweet 
  • Vegan formula not tested on animals 
  • No sharp minty taste 
  • Cleans teeth very well 
  • No fluoride that could break down enamel
Product Cons
  • Product seems to be a little runny

Dr. Sheffield’s Natural Toothpaste

Most Refreshing Taste
image
Check On Amazon

Dr. Sheffield’s Certified Natural Toothpaste in Peppermint is a great-tasting, fluoride-free toothpaste that provides long-lasting freshness, whiter teeth, and reduced plaque. This toothpaste has been known for its great taste since 1850 when it was first created to replace the common tooth powders of the time. The original recipe has been tweaked and improved over the years to ensure it provides a pleasant flavor and avoids any harmful substances or preservatives. The peppermint formula offers a cool, bracing taste that gives your breath lasting freshness for hours.

This toothpaste also has proven whitening and plaque-fighting capabilities. Regular use reduces plaque buildup on teeth and gums, making them look and feel healthier. This effect is magnified by the toothpaste’s whitening power, which helps bring out the natural whiteness in your teeth.  It has also been certified by the Natural Products Association (NPA), guaranteeing that the ingredients used to make this product are of the finest quality and have been carefully selected to maximize its effectiveness. 

Product Pros
  • The flavors are mild and refreshing
  • Includes the amazing benefits of tea tree oil
  • Doesn’t contain fluoride 
  • Great value for money 
Product Cons
  • Tea tree may not be suitable for everyone

Native Natural Toothpaste

Most Natural and Clean-Feeling
image
Check On Amazon

Native Natural Toothpaste is an effective teeth-cleaning option that whitens teeth, freshens breath, and fights cavities. True to its description, this toothpaste is made with naturally-derived cleansers and simple ingredients like fluoride to fight cavities in adults and children. It also does not contain parabens, sulfates (SLS and SLES), triclosan, or artificial preservatives. 

In terms of performance, it provides a rich foam that cleanses the teeth for a brighter smile. This natural toothpaste includes plant-derived sweeteners, making it taste great while preventing tooth decay. This product is also never tested on animals.

Product Pros
  • Prevents enamel damage
  • Excellent whitening effect
  • Foams and cleans better than other natural brands
  • Leaves mouth feeling fresh 
  • No artificial additives or weird after-taste 
Product Cons
  • Not available in recyclable containers

Davids Natural Toothpaste

Non-Toxic Ingredients
image
Check On Amazon

Davids Natural Whitening Toothpaste with Antiplaque is a premium toothpaste that promises clean and safe ingredients, gentle whitening, healthy mouth support, and sustainability. This toothpaste is fluoride-free, sulfate-free (no SLS), and contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. It has an RDA (abrasive rating) of 101 to effectively remove plaque and surface stains while being enamel-safe for daily brushing. Birch xylitol not only helps to whiten but also supports oral health. This option is also vegan, as it contains no animal by-products. 

For those looking for a toothpaste that can help provide a healthy mouth balance, this product is formulated to restore the natural PH balance of the mouth and support the oral microbiome. It works to aggressively stop plaque from forming and reduce existing plaque buildup. The product comes in a unique recyclable metal tube with a metal tube roller included to squeeze out all the toothpaste, maximizing the use of the product. Additionally, 98% of the ingredients are of US origin, providing the highest grade ingredients and qualities possible while supporting US jobs. 

Overall, this toothpaste provides an excellent solution for those looking for clean and safe ingredients. Not to mention, it offers added benefits like helping with whitening and promoting oral health while being mindful of its impact on the planet due to its metal packaging design.

Product Pros
  • No unpleasant aftertaste 
  • Contains hydroxyapatite for improved enamel health
  • Lasts a decent amount of time
  • Comes with a toothpaste extractor 
  • Non-toxic, minty taste/smell 
  • Reduces teeth sensitivity and leaves teeth feeling clean
Product Cons
  • Has a slightly funny taste for some people

Natural Toothpaste Buying Guide

Natural toothpaste can be a great alternative to traditional toothpaste for a number of reasons. Now that you’ve decided to switch to this more natural alternative for oral health, there are various considerations to ponder over.

When shopping for natural toothpaste, there are a few essential features to keep in mind. Here’s a comprehensive buyer guide that will help you find the right product for you:

Ingredients

Pay close attention to the ingredients list on the back of products; look for organic, all-natural ingredients without any artificial colors, flavors, preservatives, or sweeteners.

Flouride Content

If you’d like the extra protection provided by fluoride, look for a natural toothpaste that contains it. Most natural toothpaste is fluoride-free.

Taste

Natural toothpaste comes in a variety of flavors and textures to suit different tastes. Check reviews to make sure the flavor combination you choose will please your palate.

Texture

Natural toothpaste tends to have less foaming action than regular toothpaste due to its lack of sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS). Take note of whether you prefer creamier or pastier textures, and choose accordingly.

Whitening Power

Many natural kinds of toothpaste use natural whiteners like activated charcoal or baking soda to gently remove stains from teeth without harsh chemicals or abrasives. Consider how effective these agents are and if they suit your needs.

Cost

Price is a crucial factor because most all-natural toothpaste may be more expensive than regular ones due to their higher quality and less reliance on cheap chemicals and fillers. Adjust your budget accordingly and opt for one that checks the most boxes for you within that budget.

Reviews

Before committing to a purchase, read customer reviews of the exact product you’re considering; if there aren’t any in-depth reviews available, it might be wise to steer clear of that particular option.

Brand Reputation

Eyeing a natural toothpaste you like? Great, now do some basic research into the brand you’re purchasing from. Check out their website and see what other customers have to say about their products and overall services. A good brand should provide quality products at an affordable price and offer excellent customer service when needed.

People Also Asked

What are the benefits of using natural toothpaste?

Natural toothpaste offers a range of benefits compared to traditional toothpaste. These include being free from harsh chemicals such as fluoride and triclosan, helping to reduce the risk of irritation and allergies, reducing the build-up of plaque, protecting against gum disease, and providing essential nutrients for healthy teeth and gums.

What ingredients are included in natural toothpaste?

Natural toothpaste usually contains ingredients derived from plant sources, such as Aloe Vera, coconut oil, tea tree oil, xylitol, and baking soda. The ingredients can vary depending on the brand, but they all help to gently cleanse the teeth while providing essential nutrients that promote healthy teeth and gums.

Does natural toothpaste contain fluoride?

Most natural toothpaste does not contain fluoride. Fluoride is a chemical commonly found in traditional toothpaste that can cause irritation and allergies for some people. However, fluoride is also responsible for better foaming action and cleaner teeth. Therefore, some people may prefer natural toothpaste that contains fluoride. 

Are there any side effects associated with using natural toothpaste?

Natural toothpaste typically does not cause any side effects. However, people with sensitive teeth or gums can experience irritation when switching to natural toothpaste. If you experience discomfort or pain, it is best to speak to your dentist before using any dental product. 

Is natural toothpaste safe for children to use?

Yes, natural toothpaste is generally safe for children to use. However, as with all dental products, parents should check the ingredients carefully and consult a dentist before giving any product to children under 12. 

Does natural toothpaste work as well as traditional toothpaste?

Yes, natural toothpaste can be just as effective as traditional toothpaste at cleaning and whitening the teeth when used twice daily and combined with regular brushing and flossing. 

Where can I buy natural toothpaste?

Natural toothpaste can be bought from most supermarkets and health food stores, or online from major retailers such as Amazon or other health-focused stores. 

How often should I use natural toothpaste?

Natural toothpaste should be used twice daily after brushing with normal toothpaste. It is essential to continue regular brushing and flossing even when using natural toothpaste to ensure the maximum effectiveness of both products.  

Is it more expensive to use natural toothpaste?

The cost of natural toothpaste can vary widely depending on the type of product purchased. However, many brands are affordable compared to regular commercial toothpaste brands. Generally, buying organic products may come at a slightly higher cost than their non-organic counterparts due to the stricter regulations surrounding their manufacture and labeling.  

Does natural toothpaste taste different from traditional toothpaste?

Yes, natural toothpaste often has a different taste than traditional commercial products due to the nature of their ingredients and their lack of artificial flavorings or sweeteners. Many brands offer variations in flavors that provide unique tastes, such as mint or citrus, which can make them more enjoyable for those transitioning from traditional products.

Elevating the Shopping Game

Our platform offers in-depth reviews and analyses across various product categories, empowering you to shop with confidence and precision. Here, transparency and detailed research pave the way for smart choices that reflect your needs and values. Join our community and elevate your shopping experience from buyer to expert, one report at a time.

Contributors

Buyer's Report GUIDE Team
Buyer's Report GUIDE Team
Teeth Care
Related Reads
  • The Best Toothpaste for Sensitive Teeth That Actually Works!
  • How Much Does Teeth Whitening Cost? Comparing 5 Different Methods
  • Dental Myths and Facts: Does Oil Pulling Whiten Teeth?
  • Does Coconut Oil Whiten Teeth? Myths and Facts About DIY Teeth Whitening
  • 9 Best Teeth Whitening Kits for a Brilliant, White Smile
Back to top
logo

©2025. All Rights Reserved

  • About Us
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy
  • Terms
Contact

contact@buyersreport.guide

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you. Click here to learn more about our process.